Archive for February, 2008

A rogue’s tale

Friday, February 29th, 2008

The first we heard of MF Global’s problem in the wheat market was in a press release from CME Group Thursday morning assuring everyone that MF Global had met its obligations.

Once we heard the problem involved trading in the wheat market we didn’t think it was anything more ominous than a trader not keeping up with market volatility. After all Chicago wheat had set its all time high and Minneapolis wheat the day before had hit $25, multiples above the all time high just above $7 set in the fourth quarter. The only surprise was that the firm was MF Global instead of one of the niche grain brokers who specialize in clearing wheat traders. Several of those firms were tested in October of 2006 when a bull wheat market trapped locals bear spreading wheat in front of the commodity fund rolls to the tune of $100 million.

(more…)

Follow the leader

Wednesday, February 27th, 2008

Robert Trosten, Refco’s former chief financial officer, is the third Refco executive to plead guilty to charges of fraud and conspiracy, following the examples of Phillip Bennett, former CEO, and Santo Maggio, former executive VP. The Washington Post is reporting that Trosten is cooperating with prosecutors and faces up to 30 years in prison for bank fraud and 20 years for securities- and wire-fraud.

Tone Grant, former Refco president and Joseph Collins, of law firm Mayer Brown and Refco’s former outside counsel, are maintaining that they are not guilty and will stand trial.

Stagflation anyone?

Wednesday, February 27th, 2008

The U.S. economy was hit with a doubled barreled shot of bad news on Tuesday, which promptly caused the Dow Jones Industrial Average to rally. Perhaps it was the announcement that IBM would buy back $15 billion in stock that caused the rally but it is hard to understand how that trumped an inflationary Produced Price Index (PPI) report and a downright depressing Consumer Confidence report.

The PPI for January was up 1%, slightly better than expected with the core index (excluding food and energy) up 0.4%, which was higher than expected. The Conference Board reported that Consumer Confidence for February dropped more than 12 points to 75 from January’s 87.3 reading. The number is at its lowest level since the start of the Iraqi War in 2003. If you exclude that downward spike you have to go back to 1993 to see it this low.

(more…)

Hold the bread!

Tuesday, February 26th, 2008

If you notice people eating hamburgers or for that matter lobster sandwiches without the bun, it is not a resurgence of the Atkins diet but perhaps a financial reality.

Hard red spring wheat traded at the Minneapolis Grain Exchange (MGEX) hit the unprecedented level of $25 per bushel Monday as the bull market in grains hit hyper drive. MGEX recently received approval from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to remove price limits on the spot wheat futures contract month commencing the first business day after expiration of non-serial options on the spot month. Monday was the first day the March contract had no limits. March MGEX wheat rallied from its Friday close of $19.25 to $25 on Monday before settling at $24.

(more…)

Interest rate conundrum

Thursday, February 21st, 2008

According to a survey by Freddie Mac, U.S. fixed rate mortgages rose this week. The National average for a 30-year fixed mortgage was 6.04% on Feb. 21, up from 5.72% on Feb. 14. The Freddie Mac survey showed a rate of 5.69% on Jan. 17, the report that preceded the Federal Reserve Bank’s emergency 75 basis point easing on Jan. 22. The Fed has eased its Fed Funds rate (the rate banks charge each other) by 125 basis points (1.25%) in an eight day period in January.

If you were wondering how banks would make up the $400 billion (according to some estimates) in write downs related to the subprime debacle, increasing the rate you charge for loans while the rate you are charged drops precipitously is a good start.

(more…)

Guilty pleas in Refco drama

Thursday, February 21st, 2008

Last Friday Phillip R. Bennett, former chief executive Refco Inc., pleaded guilty to 20 counts of fraud and now faces life in prison for conspiracy, securities fraud, bank fraud and falsifying filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. This follows executive VP Santo Maggio’s confession in December, which led to him giving up $23 million. Refco executives Robert C. Trosten, Tone N. Grant and lawyer Joseph P. Collins are still facing charges and, according to the New York Times, are maintaining their innocence.

While this is certainly progress in the two year debacle, I’d like to take this opportunity to point out that the victims have still not been made whole.

More than $100 million in Refco retail customer funds were tied up in this debacle, and those retail traders have “not received a dime” of compensation, says account holder Gail Butler. And Paul Palley, one of the leaders of the Refco Account Holders group that organized on the internet and filed several law suits to get their money back is continuing the fight.

While it’s great that the NFA and the CFTC have increased their efforts to root out fraud by raising the capital requirements for FX dealers, why haven’t they stepped up to fight for these retail traders? As Bennett and Maggio have shown us, it’s never too late to do the right thing. I’d like to see NFA and the CFTC step up and do the same.

Is there a correlation between high prices and inflation?

Wednesday, February 20th, 2008

The Federal Reserve Bank released the minutes of its January Federal Open Markets Committee (FOMC) meeting and it turns out that the Fed has not completely forgotten about the risk of inflation. The minutes state, “Members were also mindful of the need for policy to promote price stability, and some noted that, when prospects for growth had improved, a reversal of a portion of the recent easing actions, possibly even a rapid reversal, might be appropriate.”

The “rapid reversal” line is particularly onerous: translated, “we really mean it this time. Really.”

This isn’t much of an acknowledgement given that the core inflation numbers — numbers many analysts will tell you are badly skewed to dampen what already could be 1970s style inflation —are currently well above the Fed’s target 2% rate. But the problem of such cautionary rhetoric from the Fed is that over the past year it has rapidly fallen by the wayside as soon as equity markets sell off.

(more…)

CME's Donohue slams DoJ letter

Tuesday, February 12th, 2008

CME Group CEO Craig Donohue provided a spirited defense of the CME clearing model that was recently questioned in a Department of Justice comment letter during a luncheon speech at the Managed Funds Association conference in Key Biscayne, Fla. Donohue called the comment letter “an ill-timed and ill-conceived suggestion,” and also pointed out that half of the positions of rogue trader Jerome Kerviel’s SocGen trades which resulted in the $7.2 billion loss were not subject to central party clearing and suggested that that helped make the fraud possible. Donohue said “the futures markets are a shining example of what could be right” with the clearing structure. John Damgard, president of the Futures Industry Association (FIA), who was also in attendance during the speech, said he thought it was surprising that Donohue would take aim at the investment banks, who are his biggest customers and substantial owners of the merc. submitted by Dan Collins

Clearing the air

Tuesday, February 12th, 2008

After the Department of Justice (DoJ) released its comment letter last week on the regulatory structure associated with financial institutions advocating the changing of regulatory policy “so as to foster exchange competition by, inter alia, ending exchange control of clearing,” we decided to ask a few trading experts what, if anything, they would like to see change in the clearing structures at CME Group or any other exchange. Based on its comment letter, the DoJ “doesn’t have a good handle on how the markets work,” says Phil Flynn, VP and senior market analyst at Alaron. The breakup of clearing from the exchanges “would hurt the U.S. markets” and make it easier for foreign competition, Flynn says. “There’s no need to break up the CME Group” from its clearing, Flynn says, adding that he thinks the clearing structure at CME works well in its current state. “They’ve been clearing trades successfully for over 100 years,” and there’s no need to change that, he says. For more on the DoJ’s comment letter and reaction from various industry players, see the March issue of Futures magazine.

A low-key rumor mill

Tuesday, February 12th, 2008

While it may not be quite the blockbuster story that a certain French bank fracas, or a certain government department brouhaha are, the proposed new futures exchange has been surrounded by its own (albeit lower-key) circle of rumors and intrigue over the past few weeks. The Financial Times reported that the Intercontinental Exchange (ICE) held “early and informal” talks with the consortium of 12 financial institutions backing the exchange, and according to the Chicago Tribune, Archipelago founder Jerry Putnam is being considered as the new exchange’s CEO. Whether or not ICE will contribute its muscle to the new exchange remains to be seen, and the CEO search appears to be ongoing, as today group spokesperson Bill McBride could not comment on either report. The consortium is interviewing “a range of accomplished and experienced executives” for leadership positions, according to McBride, who says that although the group hopes to have the positions filled by the end of February, as far as hiring was concerned, “getting it done right is better than getting it done fast.”